What are tax avoidance schemes?
Many people and businesses have used tax avoidance schemes and tax avoidance arrangements for as long as we can remember. Sometimes these are bespoke and tailored and sometimes they are mass marketed; designed to reduce the user’s tax liabilities. However, HMRC have become better and better at identifying tax avoidance and challenging it. They do this through regular compliance checks, tax investigations, and tax avoidance specific measures like DOTAS and POTAS, Accelerated Payment Notices and Follower Notices.
It used to take HMRC many years to be alerted to the use of mass marketed schemes, from which they then gathered intelligence, facts and evidence, before deciding on how to pursue the tax avoidance scheme users, and only latterly started looking at those that had created and promoted the arrangements. Many tax avoidance arrangements have been created and marketed over many decades, all purporting to reduce the user’s tax liabilities or fully mitigate them.
Some readers will recognise historic planning which generated losses (commonly from film investment schemes) which were then used against other taxable income / profits, as well as arrangements utilising Employee Benefit Trusts to divert otherwise personally taxable income into tax-free loans via a separate entity, whilst securing corporate tax deductions, and many more arrangements targeting directors, employees and contractors to side-step PAYE consequences. Needless to say that these were almost all marketed therefore they were not tailored / bespoke at all.
Where once upon a time, users regularly escaped penalties for partaking in tax avoidance, HMRC changed the balance by introducing measures to penalise serial tax avoiders. Also, in recent years, we have seen HMRC become much better at pursuing tax avoidance scheme creators/promoters. Thy do this by investigating them, publicly naming and shaming them, and much more clearly highlighting them in the press. Afterall, they have historically caused the majority of tax avoidance users to being exposed to taxes they sought to minimise or mitigate fully, plus highly punitive statutory late payment interest (which has a particularly painful compounding effect) and sometimes non-financial too.
Importantly, HMRC win almost all tax avoidance litigation cases that are taken to the tribunal, which promoters don’t want scheme users to focus on.
What should I do about my Tax Avoidance Scheme?
Most, not all, people know that they have taken part in some sort of tax avoidance or planning when we meet them. However, most of the time they believe the tax avoidance arrangement was vanilla and ‘everybody did it’ so it was normalised in some way, and therefore generally accepted by HMRC. It follows that its quite common for users of such arrangements to refer to the promoters having cited having supporting barristers’ opinions and even HMRC’s blessings in some way.
However, this has always misleading, because the legal opinions sometimes relate to plans that were then not implemented exactly in the way envisaged and/or they overly focused on the individual steps in the planning rather than the overall goal of the tax avoidance.
It’s important to know that HMRC do not approve tax avoidance schemes, despite them needing to be notified about them all under DOTAS rules. Those rules allow HMRC to track who has created them (and where the rules work well, those that additionally promoted those arrangements), what the arrangements purport to do and achieve, as well as identify all the users of the tax avoidance scheme.
If you or your client have used a tax avoidance scheme in the past and have suffered whilst HMRC has been pursuing you or your client, then we can help with engaging HMRC and evaluating the merits of a settlement. By using tax investigation specialists you will get experienced and expert support in ensuring that HMRC can only pursue taxes that they are entitled to.
For example, we will ensure that only amounts assessed at the correct times by following the strict rules for timing and reliant on particular actions / behaviours being established are used, nothing voluntary in nature, and that HMRC have followed their strict enquiry cover provisions, i.e. that they have properly concluded enquiries that were properly opened and so were valid. We appreciate that users have to swallow a bitter pill in accepting HMRC’s challenge that the tax avoidance planning does not work and as such that the promised financial result cannot be achieved.
We then analyse and test HMRC’s tax computations. It’s important to remember that late payment interest charges follow the taxes payable. There is usually scope to find savings in relation to both. Also, crucially, we understand HMRC’s myriad of published tax avoidance settlement opportunities, which are normally time-sensitive and scheme-specific, but not always expired for real-time settlements. For example, we can sometimes achieve preferential settlements where statutory interest charges are foregone by HMRC in line with an expired settlement opportunity, e.g. in certain Disguised Remuneration cases.
Once you or your client is armed with details about what HMRC can and are pursuing, you will appreciate what needs to be agreed in the alternative to litigating and being forced to continue paying the scheme promoters (who encourage fighting for larger groups of scheme users). That is in the clear knowledge that HMRC win almost every tax avoidance litigation case that gets to the tribunal.
This is why users come to us to explore settlement options, to withdraw themselves from historic tax avoidance schemes which were widely marketed in the past. We help users understand the benefits of settling and having that piece of mind and finality, by ensuring one makes an informed choice buy only with the relevant data to hand.
Should I settle my tax avoidance scheme with HMRC?
As part of our work we will ensure that the settlement is negotiated correctly and is the lowest it can reasonably be in terms of tax reliefs / exemptions, enquiry cover, challenging tax assessments, and reducing interest charges. So, for the sake of certainty and already knowing the likely outcome at a tribunal hearing (a win for HMRC, although not guaranteed), yes, it’s more often than not the right decision to make. However, if you and your client’s risk and stress appetite is greater and/or financial position means that litigation costs can be borne, then a settlement at this juncture may not be preferred but should still be evaluated.
If I settle my tax avoidance case can I pay HMRC in instalments?
If a negotiated settlement cannot be funded in full then you or your client will need to consider proposing a Time to Pay (HMRC TTP) arrangement to HMRC. One cannot simply choose not to pay HMRC in full if one can, where e.g. additional taxes are agreed. An HMRC TTP arrangement puts forward a payments plan with or without a lump sum at the beginning.
We need to forecast incomings and outgoings so there is sufficient income and that other financial commitments can be ensured too. Shorter payment plans are preferred by HMRC but every case is considered on its own merits. Our job is to negotiate with HMRC on yours or your client’s behalf, demonstrating how reasonable the TTP is, to secure a manageable payment plan. Such plans are fairly common in the circumstances.
What is DOTAS?
Disclosure of Tax Avoidance Schemes (DOTAS), is a long-running regime which was designed to compel creators of tax avoidance arrangements to disclose them to HMRC early on. The arrangement is then given a specific scheme reference number that must be passed to all the scheme’s users who must in turn put those on their own tax returns. Importantly, having a DOTAS scheme reference number does not mean that a creator’s arrangements are approved by HMRC nor does that mean users are free from the risk of an enquiry or investigation.
What is POTAS?
Promoters of Tax Avoidance Schemes (POTAS) rules reinforced DOTAS and went even further. They target the creators of tax avoidance arrangements with the aim for deterring them and those associated with them. Promoters are more closely monitored, as are their interactions with associates and users of those arrangements. Importantly, the POTAS regime involves a series of sanctions like a stop notice; a conduct notice and a monitoring notice, which can immediately stop the marketing of or greatly slow down a new tax avoidance scheme.
What is an APN?
Accelerated Payment Notice (APN) is a financial action. HMRC compel users of tax avoidance schemes to pay the potential tax saved up-front, while the arguments within the enquiry / investigation and/or litigation continue. We can help check their accuracy and therefore the figures as well as negotiate a Time to Pay arrangement as above.
What is a Follower Notice?
A Follower Notice is another financial action which allows HMRC to pursue users of a tax avoidance scheme where key principles of those arrangements have already been defeated in litigation of a similar scheme. HMRC will seek to amend the users’ tax returns or commence settlement negotiations promptly. We can help check their accuracy and manage negotiations as appropriate, including a Time to Pay arrangement as above.
So all is not lost in Tax Avoidance Schemes?
No, careful and skilled management of tax avoidance cases is a must, because litigation is a formal process and it requires diligent management as to time-lines and adhering to tribunal case management directions. Also, despite HMRC winning almost all tax avoidance cases in the courts, there are still settlement opportunities available that can cushion the blow for users of schemes, and so a closer look at what HMRC have done and can do is required, to identify savings in a settlement. We always focus HMRC’s attention on progressing towards a conclusion; that is more important than some realise – contact us without delay. We can expedite conclusions and reduce exposure to statutory interest in some cases and fight-off penalty conversations too.
How we can help?
We deliver that all-important trusted ‘buffer’ between our clients and HMRC during their sometimes in-depth and intrusive investigations, in voluntary disclosures, in the settlement of tax avoidance cases and in Time to Pay negotiations too.
Get in touch to learn more about how Amit and the Tax Investigations and Disputes team have successfully guided clients through the WDF disclosure, compliance checks, COP9 or COP8 investigation processes.
Learn more about how we have helped our clients through their kind feedback here.
HOW CAN PURE TAX HELP?
At Pure Tax our Tax Investigation & Disclosure specialists are industry recognised and have dealt with hundreds of contentious situations with HMRC over the years. We are adept at managing interactions with the tax authorities to ensure that the investigation and disclosure processes run smoothly and that your interests are best protected.













